PAS Papers Box 4A Manumissions
Actions involving illegal enslavement of free blacks, 1787-1830
Two Persons from Maryland attended by Counsel C.P. Holerman applied to the Rcdr of the City of Philadea to hear the case of an alleged slave a woman whom the younger of the two had arresteds with much brutality under by a warrt granted under Oath and had illegally committed to Prison The Recorder immediately had the alleged slave brot before him al and proceeded to hear the case without without any counsel being present on behalf of the prisoner The claimant then produced his brother E T Massey who swore that the prisoner was the slave of his brother the claimant to whom he had sold her that he had purchased her at the sheriff’s sale of his Father’s effects who had become insolvent that her mother had been the Slave of his Grandfather from who his father received her by inheritance & in whose possession she died a Slave Fortunately for the Prisoner a Coloured Man of respectable appearance was present and testified the prisoners mother had been manumitted before his birth by the grandfather of the claimt The Massey’s being known to the recorder as respectable man he gave no credence to the story of the manumission of the mother which the claimant his brother pronounced to be false ?the testimony of E Massey was taken in writing & he suffered to go home? A postponement was granted the Pennsa Sociy was applied to who procured able counsel for the woman at the next hearing there being no witness on the part of the claimant the Counsel D P Brown  G Griscom Chas Gilpin endeavoured to set aside the evidence of E T Massey on the ground of at interest having been the Seller and of course bound to make her title good the objectn was overuled by Recorder J McIlraine  who the a manumn of the Mother & several other Slaves was then produced on which was indorsed a certificate of of the witness himself E T Massey after perusing it the Rcdr handed it to the claimant enquiring whether [it] was genuine he hesitated said he had never [text covered over] of it he was then enquired of whether that was not her brother’s Certificate on the back he said he could not tell he had an uncle of the same name
The plaintiffs counsel then contended that the Girl was born since the date of the manumissn and was not 22 years old The Cold man was again brought forward who stated positively that she was not__but the Recorder willing to shew the Slave holder a favor granted time to procure further evidence which he alleged he could procure by half the county he lived in. the friends of the Girl entered security for her appearance and a few days afterward an offer was made to sell her which was indignantly rejected at the appd time No claimant appeared but the Recorder as if infatuated declared had he came he would have delivered the woman to him as a Slave a Certificate was since produced from the County office by which it appeared Massey the Grandfather left no slave & on examination it was found that the Sheriffs sold no Slave of B Massey the father Comment is unnecessary
a/c of Slave Case
 David Paul Brown was a prominent attorney in Philadelphia and resided at Washington Square. Desilver’s Philadelphia Directory and Stranger’s Guide, 1830, 22. Brown throughout the 1820s and ‘30s was associated with the Pennsylvania Abolition Society as their “energetic and distinguished consellor.” Edward Needles, An Historical Memoir of the Pennsylvania Society, for Promoting the Abolition of Slavery (1848; Arno Press reprint, New York, 1969), 93.
 Joseph McIlvaine was an attorney in Philadelphia as well as the Recorder of the City of Philadelphia in 1830. He lived at 1 South Ninth Street. Desilver’s Philadelphia Directory and Stranger’s Guide, 1830, 122.