Teaching the Civil War through Political Cartoons

HomeEducationUnit PlansVisual Culture and the Civil WarTeaching the Civil War through Political Cartoons

Teaching the Civil War through Political Cartoons

This Lesson Plan explores Political Cartoons related to the Civil War, the Presidential Elections of 1860 and 1864, and Reconstruction. These visual aids help in understanding the differing opinions before, during, and after the Civil War, as well as provide a perspective from those who actually lived it. The cartoons are listed in chronological order so teachers are meant to pick and choose as needed for lessons relating to the Civil War. General background knowledge needed for each cartoon is provided as well in a PowerPoint.

Funders/Sponsors: 

PA Common Core Standards:

8.6. 9-12 A

8.5.9-12 A,B,D,F

Partner:

Essential Questions

How has social disagreement and collaboration been beneficial to American society?
What role does analysis have in historical construction?

Objectives

Students will be able to:

• Identify point of view and conflicting opinions by analyzing political cartoons.
• Analyze the causes and effects of the civil war by comparing and contrasting political cartoons from before, during, and after the Civil War.

Suggested Instructional Procedures

1. Prior to using the cartoons, teachers can utilize the General Background Knowledge PowerPoint in order to choose which cartoons will work best as teaching tools or assessment pieces. The PowerPoint contains both background knowledge and vocabulary for each cartoon followed by the cartoons.

2. First, go over vocabulary and common symbols worksheet. Have students fill out the vocabulary that corresponds with the cartoons being used and allow them to keep the symbols worksheet with them as they look at the cartoons to help them understand their meaning.

3. Take out the Political Cartoon Analysis Worksheet and together as a class show students how to analyze a cartoon. Use the cartoon, “The True Issue, or That’s What’s the Matter” to model cartoon analysis. Follow the Phases and Questions below and repeat for other cartoons.

Observation Phase: Remember to record observations.

• What objects do you see?
• Write down the cartoon caption (if there is one).
• Locate words or phrases and decipher meaning.

Reflection Phase: Remember to record observations.

• Symbolism and metaphors: A symbol in a cartoon is an image that is created to mean some other thing, person, idea, etc.  A metaphor uses an analogy to describe one thing as similar to something completely different.

o What is being ripped by Jefferson David and Abraham Lincoln?
o What is George McClellan's role in this?
o What does the map symbolize?


• Irony/Satire: Form of humor that is especially appropriate for political cartoons because it mocks the direct meaning of the image and represents a contradiction to that meaning.

o What was McClellan known as? What were Davis and Lincoln known as? Is any of this contradictory to previous knowledge?

• Stereotype: Oversimplification of a particular group. How are the characters or items shown in the cartoon represented? Which images are large and which are small?

  • How does the author stereotype each character?

• Exaggeration: A distortion of an object that enhances and highlights the aspect the author would like to become dominant to the viewer.

  • What aspects of the cartoon are exaggerated to make the audience notice them?
  • What emotions do you see? Are any emotions exaggerated?

Question Phase: Remember to record observations.

  • What is the message of the political cartoon?
  • What is the author trying to tell the audience? Knowing the background knowledge of this time period, does the message surprise you?
  • What attitude does the author have toward the Presidential Election of 1864?
  • How does this relate to the Civil War? Which side of the conflict is this author portraying?
  • How does this relate to what you already know about the Civil War, and how does it fit in with the larger picture of US History? Does it surprise you or does it seem consistent with other aspects of US History?

4. Answers should be discussed as a class. Then students may work in pairs or individually to fill in the columns for all cartoons assigned.

5. As an optional assessment, have students create their own political cartoon relating to the Civil War.
 

Vocabulary

“Buck and Breck”: Nickname referring to Buchanan and Breckenridge.

“The Railsplitter”: This was President Abraham Lincoln’s nickname, used most often during the 1860 Presidential Election. It refers to the manual labor he completed for wages as a young man living on the frontier. The nickname was given to him to help his political appeal with workingmen.

“The Tennessee Tailor”: Nickname for President Andrew Johnson because he worked as a tailor prior to going into politics.

Andrew Jackson: President of the United States from 1829-1837. He was known as a strong leader against issues that arose within his cabinet. Rather than appeasing them, he discharged those he felt were hurting his administration.

Andrew Johnson: President of the United States from 1865-1869. He was Abraham Lincoln’s Vice President and he became President after Lincoln’s assassination. He was known as a Southern sympathizer during Reconstruction because he vetoed several bills, including one that excluded representatives from states with Black Codes to serve, and he openly opposed the Fourteenth Amendment.

Confederacy: Refers to the Southern States that seceded and became the Confederate States of America.

Draft or Conscription: Compulsory enlistment of armed forces in a time of war.

Foul ball: In baseball, if you hit the ball outside the parameters of the base lines it is considered a foul.

George McClellan: Nicknamed Little Mac. He was a general during the Civil War and a presidential candidate during the 1864 election. He ran under the pretense of preserving the Union at all costs and he attempted to appease both Northerners and Southerners.

James Buchanan: President of the United States from 1857-1861. He is generally remembered as one of the worst presidents.

Jefferson Davis: President of the Confederate States of America. After the surrender of the South and Lincoln’s assassination, there was a 100,000 dollar reward put outby President Andrew Johnson.for Davis' capture.  There was a rumor that he wore his wife’s overcoat while fleeing.

John Bell: Ran in the 1860 election under the Constitutional Union party.

John Breckenridge: Vice President from 1857-1861 and then a presidential candidate in the 1860 election. He was the Southern Democratic candidate and Buchanan openly endorsed him.

Ku Klux Klan: Also known as the KKK. They began in the south during reconstruction and were extremely violent against African Americans. The original KKK was started by six Confederate Army Veterans.

Short Stop: A position in baseball located on the infield.

Skunk Rule: In baseball, a team is skunked when there is no way they can win so the game ends before the other team can run up the score even more. Also known as the “Mercy Rule.”

Stephen Douglas: Political adversary to President Lincoln and a presidential candidate in the 1860 election. He campaigned hard for an union between northern and southern Democrats, yet it did not work and Abraham Lincoln was elected President.